Journal of Law, Economics, and Organization Advance Access published online on September 7, 2009
Journal of Law, Economics, and Organization, doi:10.1093/jleo/ewp022
Noneconomic Damage Caps and Medical Malpractice Claim Frequency: A Policy Endogeneity Approach
University of North Carolina-Chapel Hill
* Department of Public Policy, University of North Carolina-Chapel Hill, Campus Box 3435, Chapel Hill, NC 27599, USA. Email: christine.durrance{at}unc.edu.
Medical malpractice has received much attention in the media with highly publicized jury awards and reported consequences of excessive litigation. Health care and medical malpractice remain a prominent issue, especially in the current political climate. Policy endogeneity, however, plagues most analyses of various federal, state, or local policies. In this article, I analyze the effect of noneconomic damage caps on the frequency of positive payment medical malpractice claims, recognizing that these laws are likely endogenous. I construct a unique instrument using past and current values of state political composition and other factors. In contrast to previous literature, I find no evidence that caps on noneconomic damages are associated with a reduction in medical malpractice positive payment claim frequency. (JEL K13, I18)